Jan 30, 2011 1
Is Nigglature Acceptable Literature?
Posted by Ariel Cherie
I watched a trailer for an upcoming documentary called Behind Those Books on urban novels. The general consensus was that since most of the plots involved sex, drugs, just general explicit content was not appropriate for young people to read since it glorified the hood.
The directors interviewed authors such as K’wan, Teri Woods, Omar Tyree and Terry McMillan on the issue. Most of the authors (and this is based off of the 13-minute trailer) was that black people want to read things they can relate to and will be interested in, even if the subjects are hypersexualized.
And as long as people are reading, we should be happy, right? It’s not that simple. Check the clip.
I agree reading something in any form is great. We feel like the younger generations are too dependent on electronics, whether it be smartphones, iPods, or video games (hey, we even have e-books), so to see a teenager actually flipping through the pages of a book is wonderful. Despite the recycled plot lines, there’s a LOT of typos in these books. Sometimes the mistakes, if there’s a ton, take away from the actual content of the book and enjoyment. Think about it: if your child is reading a book that is laden with poor grammar and misspellings, how do you think they will perform as a writer in their everyday life? I’ll tell you, they’re going to be the ones we laugh at and go in on Twitter, when they say things like, “flaming young” versus “filet mignon.” *Sigh*
One of the points made by Queen Pen in the trailer was that black people can’t identify with some white books like the Harry Potter series because black people can’t identify with “warlocks.” Umm… am I missing something? Last time I checked, I didn’t see any white warlocks walking down the street. That’s a poor excuse. Lack of imagination is abundant in urban lit. You have the creative control to create anything you want to, yet you choose to do the same thing over and over again. How can you grow as an author?
Most importantly, I don’t think is a problem if someone reads nigglature at all. However, if that’s all you read then there lies the problem. I believe we should all be well-read in order to get a wider scope of life. If you read B More Careful by Shannon Holmes , then you should have read Their Eyes Were Watching God by Zora Neale Hurton as well.
Just think, if you read five books that have the same basic plot, what are you getting out of it? Would you even recommend it? “Yea, girl, you should read [insert cliched title here]. It’s just like every other book I ever read. Mmhmm. I’ll let you borrow my copy.” Uhh, I’ll pass. Imagine if you read a play, like Raisin in the Sun, or a nonfiction book, like Immortality of Influence, or even one by a non-Black author such as The Namesake by Jhumpa Lahiri. There’s a wide variety of stories that someone might not have known about that they may be interested in. They’re great to bring up in conversation.
All I’m saying is try to expand your readings. You just might like it.





Recent Comments